13 · Newtonian Mechanics
Chapter 13

Newtonian Mechanics

Newton's law of motion says that the force on a body is its mass times its acceleration. Acceleration is a second derivative, so this law is a differential equation, and it is the reason the subject exists. Newton developed calculus in large part to study motion, and for centuries differential equations meant, above all, the equations of mechanics: a falling stone, a swinging pendulum, the planets going around the sun.

In this chapter we bring everything we have built to Newton's law. We will see that for a system of many pieces it is a large nonlinear system, so its equilibria, its linearizations, and its phase portraits are all within reach of our tools. We will also see physics give something back: the energy of a mechanical system never changes, and that simple fact turns out to be a powerful method of its own, useful far beyond physics.

13.1Newton's Law

Newton's law says that the force on a body equals its mass times its acceleration. Suppose a system has 𝑁 pieces: masses on springs, atoms in a molecule, planets around a sun. Write 𝑋𝑖 for the position of piece 𝑖 and 𝑚𝑖 for its mass. The force on piece 𝑖 depends on where all the pieces are, so

𝑚𝑖𝑋″𝑖=𝐹𝑖(𝑋1,…,𝑋𝑁),𝑖=1,…,𝑁.

Stack all the positions into one long vector 𝑋 =(𝑋1,…,𝑋𝑁) and all the forces into 𝐹 =(𝐹1,…,𝐹𝑁). Then Newton's law is a single equation,

𝑀𝑋″=𝐹(𝑋),

where 𝑀 is the diagonal matrix that multiplies each piece's coordinates by its mass. As a first-order system, the state is the position 𝑋 together with the velocity 𝑋′. So 𝑁 pieces moving in the plane have a state with 4𝑁 numbers. Three stars in the plane, as in section 11.4, already have a 12-dimensional state.

And the forces are almost never linear in 𝑋. Gravity weakens with distance, and a spring pulls along its own direction, which changes as it tilts. So Newton's law for a system of many pieces is a large nonlinear system.

13.2One-Dimensional Motion

Many mechanical systems have only one way to move. A bead threaded on a wire can only slide along the wire, a pendulum can only swing around its circle, and a mass on a spring in a track can only slide back and forth. The position of such a system is a single number 𝑥. But Newton's law involves the second derivative, so the state is the position together with the velocity 𝑣 =𝑥′, and the motion is a system in the plane. Planar systems describe exactly the motions with one way to move. A particle moving freely in space is a different matter: it has three coordinates of position and three of velocity, so its state is six numbers.

Taking the mass to be 1, Newton's law is 𝑥″ =𝐹, and the force can depend on the position and on the velocity. The force of a spring depends only on its stretch, and the force of gravity on a pendulum depends only on its angle. These are position-dependent forces. Drag from air or water is a velocity-dependent force: it is zero when the particle is at rest and opposes the motion otherwise. When both kinds are present,

𝑥″=𝑃(𝑥)+𝐷(𝑥′),

where 𝑃(𝑥) is the position-dependent force and 𝐷(𝑥′) is the drag, with 𝐷(0) =0. As a system,

𝑥′=𝑣,𝑣′=𝑃(𝑥)+𝐷(𝑣).

To see what these systems do, let's look at a bead on a wire. Write 𝑠 for the distance along the wire from a fixed point, and ℎ(𝑠) for the height of the wire there. Two forces act on the bead: gravity, pulling down with strength 𝑔, and the push of the wire, which keeps the bead on it. The wire can only push perpendicular to itself, so along the wire, only gravity counts. The unit vector along the wire has vertical component ℎ′(𝑠), so the component of gravity along the wire is −𝑔 ℎ′(𝑠). The acceleration along the wire is 𝑠″, so with air resistance −𝑐𝑠′, Newton's law along the wire is

𝑠″=−𝑔ℎ′(𝑠)−𝑐𝑠′.

The position-dependent force is 𝑃(𝑠) = −𝑔 ℎ′(𝑠), and the drag is 𝐷(𝑠′) = −𝑐𝑠′.

Take a W-shaped wire, with height ℎ(𝑠) =𝐴( −12𝑠2 +14𝑠4), where 𝐴 >0 is small enough that the wire is never steeper than vertical on the piece we use. Then −𝑔 ℎ′(𝑠) =𝑔𝐴(𝑠 −𝑠3), so

𝑠″=𝑔𝐴(𝑠−𝑠3)−𝑐𝑠′.

We are mathematicians, so we take the constant 𝑔𝐴 to be 1:

𝑠″=𝑠−𝑠3−𝑐𝑠′,

the double well from chapter 11, now with a physical meaning.

Figure 13.1 Left: a bead on a W-shaped wire, with heights drawn four times larger. Right: trajectories of 𝑠′ =𝑣, 𝑣′ =𝑠 −𝑠3 −𝑐𝑣. Move the slider to change the drag 𝑐, and click the right picture to release the bead.

Now the general picture. At an equilibrium, 𝑣 =0 and 𝑃(𝑥0) +𝐷(0) =0. Since 𝐷(0) =0, the equilibria are the states (𝑥0,0) with 𝑃(𝑥0) =0: drag doesn't create or remove them. For the bead, they are the points where the wire is level, ℎ′(𝑠) =0: the top of the middle hump, 𝑠 =0, and the two bottoms, 𝑠 = ±1. The Jacobian at an equilibrium is

𝐽=(01𝑃′(𝑥0)𝐷′(0)).

Its trace comes only from the drag, and its determinant, −𝑃′(𝑥0), comes only from the position-dependent force.

If 𝑃′(𝑥0) >0, a small displacement from 𝑥0 produces a force away from 𝑥0. The determinant is negative, so the equilibrium is a saddle, for any drag. For the bead, 𝑃′(0) =1: a bead balanced on top of the hump falls to one side or the other unless it starts exactly right.

If 𝑃′(𝑥0) <0, a small displacement produces a force back toward 𝑥0, and the determinant is positive. With drag, 𝐷′(0) = −𝑐 <0, so the equilibrium is a sink. It is a spiral sink when 𝑐2 <4|𝑃′(𝑥0)|. For the bead, 𝑃′( ±1) = −2, so when 𝑐2 <8 the bead rocks back and forth in the dip, less each time, and comes to rest at the bottom. With more drag, it slides to the bottom without rocking.

A velocity-dependent force can do more than slow things down. Van der Pol's equation from section 11.2, 𝑥″ = −𝑥 +(1 −𝑥2)𝑥′, has a velocity-dependent force that speeds up small motions and slows large ones, and every motion settles onto a single attracting loop. With velocity-dependent forces, sinks, sources, and attracting loops all appear in one-dimensional mechanics.

Now remove the drag, so that the force depends only on position: 𝑥″ =𝑃(𝑥). The trace is 0. Where 𝑃′(𝑥0) >0, the equilibrium is still a saddle. Where 𝑃′(𝑥0) <0, it is a center. (Where 𝑃′(𝑥0) =0, linearization fails.) There are no sinks and no sources. Set the drag to zero in the figure: the bottoms of the wire become centers, and the top of the hump stays a saddle.

Figure 13.2 Left: the graph of a force 𝑃(𝑥); drag the points to change it. Right: trajectories of 𝑥″ =𝑃(𝑥). Each zero of 𝑃 is an equilibrium.

At a center, linearization can't decide what happens. Here a symmetry decides it. If (𝑥(𝑡),𝑣(𝑡)) solves 𝑥′ =𝑣, 𝑣′ =𝑃(𝑥), then so does (𝑥( −𝑡), −𝑣( −𝑡)): reflect a trajectory across the 𝑥-axis and reverse its direction, and you get another trajectory. Now take an equilibrium 𝑥0 with 𝑃′(𝑥0) <0, and start a state on the 𝑥-axis just to its right, at (𝑎,0). Near the equilibrium the flow turns like its linearization, so the state goes around below 𝑥0 and returns to the axis on the other side, at some (𝑏,0). Reflecting this arc gives a trajectory from (𝑏,0) back to (𝑎,0) through the upper half-plane. By uniqueness, that is how the state continues. So it returns to (𝑎,0) and goes around again: the trajectory is a closed loop, and the motion is periodic.

So when the forces depend only on position, the equilibria are saddles and centers, and near every center the motion repeats. The same symmetry rules out sinks entirely, even where linearization fails: reversing time turns a sink into a source, so an equilibrium that drew in every nearby state would also have to push them all away. Sinks need a velocity-dependent force.

13.3Energy Conservation

In section 13.2 we learned what happens near the equilibria of 𝑥″ =𝑃(𝑥): they are saddles and centers, and near a center the motion repeats. That says nothing about states far from an equilibrium. Release the bead from rest high on the left wall of the W. Does it stay in the left dip, or does it cross the hump in the middle? In section 11.1 we claimed that a state released at rest from √2 has exactly enough energy to climb back to the top of the hump. Now we can make that precise.

The question is about where the bead goes, not when it gets there. So instead of looking for the solution 𝑥(𝑡), let's look for the curve the state traces in the (𝑥,𝑣)-plane.

What do we know about that curve? At every state, the system gives us the velocity arrow, (𝑥′,𝑣′) =(𝑣,𝑃(𝑥)), and the trajectory through that state follows its arrow. The length of the arrow tells us how fast the state moves along the curve: that's the when, which we don't care about. The direction of the arrow tells us which way the curve goes, and that direction is a slope, rise over run:

𝑣′𝑥′=𝑃(𝑥)𝑣.

So at every state with 𝑣 ≠0 we know the slope of the trajectory through it. That is a slope field, just like the ones in section 1.2, with 𝑥 in place of time and 𝑣 in place of the unknown. The trajectories are its solution curves, so they solve

𝑑𝑣𝑑𝑥=𝑃(𝑥)𝑣.

For the bead, 𝑑𝑣𝑑𝑠 =𝑠−𝑠3𝑣. We have traded a system of two equations for a single first-order equation, and this one we can solve, because it is separable (section 2.3). Separating and integrating,

𝑣𝑑𝑣=𝑃(𝑥)𝑑𝑥,12𝑣2=∫𝑃(𝑥)𝑑𝑥+𝐶.

Write 𝑉(𝑥) for an antiderivative of −𝑃, so that 𝑉′ = −𝑃. Then 12𝑣2 +𝑉(𝑥) =𝐶. This is an implicit solution, as in definition 2.3: each trajectory lies on a level curve of the function

𝐸(𝑥,𝑣)=12𝑣2+𝑉(𝑥).

We needed 𝑣 ≠0 to find 𝐸, but we can check directly that it works everywhere. Along any solution, by the chain rule,

𝐸′=𝑣𝑣′+𝑉′(𝑥)𝑥′=𝑣𝑃(𝑥)−𝑃(𝑥)𝑣=0.

So 𝐸 never changes. The function 𝑉 is called the potential energy, 12𝑣2 the kinetic energy, and 𝐸 the energy. The fact that 𝐸 is constant is conservation of energy. For the bead, 𝑃(𝑠) = −𝑔 ℎ′(𝑠), so we can take 𝑉(𝑠) =𝑔 ℎ(𝑠): the potential energy is 𝑔 times the height of the wire. With our choice 𝑔𝐴 =1, 𝑉(𝑠) = −12𝑠2 +14𝑠4.

Since each trajectory stays on one level curve of 𝐸, we can draw the phase portrait without solving anything: we just draw the level curves. Solving for 𝑣,

𝑣=±√2(𝐸−𝑉(𝑥)).

A state with energy 𝐸 can only be where 𝑉(𝑥) ≤𝐸. It moves fastest where 𝑉 is lowest, and it stops and turns around where 𝑉(𝑥) =𝐸.

Figure 13.3 Left: the graph of the potential 𝑉, with a gold line at the energy 𝐸. Right: the level curve of 𝐸 in the (𝑥,𝑣)-plane, which is the trajectory with that energy. Move the slider to change 𝐸, and use the buttons to choose the force.

Now back to the bead. Released from rest at 𝑠0, it has energy 𝐸 =𝑉(𝑠0). The top of the hump is at 𝑠 =0, where 𝑉(0) =0. The bottoms of the dips are at 𝑠 = ±1, where 𝑉 = −14, and 𝑉 climbs back to 0 at 𝑠 = ±√2. If |𝑠0| <√2, then 𝐸 <0, and since the bead can only be where 𝑉(𝑠) ≤𝐸 <0, it can never reach 𝑠 =0. It stays in its own dip. It swings between 𝑠0 and the other point on the same side where 𝑉(𝑠) =𝑉(𝑠0), which is the point at the same height. Released at 𝑠0 =1.3, it swings between 1.3 and about 0.56. If |𝑠0| >√2, then 𝐸 >0, and the hump is no barrier. The bead swings across both dips, out to −𝑠0 and back. Released at exactly √2, it has 𝐸 =0 and lies on the figure-eight of section 11.1.

The equilibria are where 𝑃(𝑥0) =0, which are exactly the points where 𝑉′(𝑥0) =0. Where 𝑃′(𝑥0) <0, we have 𝑉″(𝑥0) >0, so 𝑥0 is a local minimum of 𝑉. These are the centers of section 13.2. Where 𝑃′(𝑥0) >0, 𝑥0 is a local maximum of 𝑉, a saddle. The bead's centers are the bottoms of the dips, and its saddle is the top of the hump.

Energy also shows how far the repeating motion extends. Take a local minimum 𝑥0 of 𝑉 and an energy 𝐸 a little above 𝑉(𝑥0). Near 𝑥0, the positions with 𝑉(𝑥) ≤𝐸 form an interval 𝑎 ≤𝑥 ≤𝑏, with 𝑉(𝑎) =𝑉(𝑏) =𝐸. Over that interval, the level curve of 𝐸 is a closed loop. On its top half, 𝑣 >0 and the state moves right. On its bottom half, 𝑣 <0 and it moves left. The two halves meet at the turning points 𝑎 and 𝑏. As long as 𝑥0 is the only zero of 𝑉′ on [𝑎,𝑏], there is no equilibrium on the loop. Then the state's speed through the plane never drops to zero, it goes all the way around in a finite time, and it starts over. The motion is periodic. For the bead, this holds for every energy between −14 and 0, so every motion that stays in one dip repeats.

For the stiffening spring 𝑥″ = −𝑥 −𝑥3 from section 12.4, 𝑉 =12𝑥2 +14𝑥4. Its only critical point is the minimum at 0, and it grows without bound in both directions. So every energy 𝐸 >0 gives a closed loop: every motion of the stiffening spring is periodic, however large.

Energy works even where linearization fails. For 𝑥″ = −𝑥3, 𝑃′(0) =0, so the Jacobian at the origin has determinant 0. In section 13.2 we could not classify this equilibrium. But 𝑉 =14𝑥4 has a minimum at 0 and no other critical point, so again every motion is periodic.

The pendulum 𝑥″ = −sin⁡𝑥 has 𝑉 = −cos⁡𝑥. Its minima, at 𝑥 =0, ±2𝜋,…, are all the same hanging position. Its maxima, at 𝑥 = ±𝜋, are the pendulum balanced upside down, where 𝑉 =1. With energy below 1, the pendulum swings back and forth around a closed loop. With energy above 1, 12𝑣2 =𝐸 −𝑉 ≥𝐸 −1 >0, so 𝑣 is never zero, and the pendulum goes all the way over the top, again and again. With energy exactly 1, it lies on the curves through the maxima, which separate the two kinds of motion.

Now add drag: 𝑥″ =𝑃(𝑥) +𝐷(𝑥′). Then

𝐸′=𝑣𝑣′+𝑉′(𝑥)𝑣=𝑣(𝑃(𝑥)+𝐷(𝑣))−𝑃(𝑥)𝑣=𝑣𝐷(𝑣).

Drag opposes the motion, so 𝐷(𝑣) has the opposite sign to 𝑣, and 𝑣𝐷(𝑣) <0 whenever 𝑣 ≠0. Energy decreases whenever the state is moving. For the bead, 𝐸′ = −𝑐𝑣2. (We have seen this before. For the springs 𝑥″ = −𝑥 ∓(𝑥′)3 in section 12.4, the quantity 𝑥2 +𝑣2 we followed is 2𝐸, and (𝑥2 +𝑣2)′ = ∓2𝑣4 is this formula with 𝐷(𝑣) = ∓𝑣3.)

Once the bead's energy drops below 0, the potential energy at the top of the hump, the bead can never reach 𝑠 =0 again. It is trapped in whichever dip it is in at that moment. This is why the basins in figure 11.3 come in bands. A bead released far out starts with a lot of energy, and it crosses the hump again and again, losing energy as it goes. The dip it ends in is the one it is in when its energy drops below 0.

The same computation works for many pieces. Suppose there is one function 𝑉(𝑋) of all the positions such that the force on each piece is 𝐹𝑖 = −∇𝑖𝑉, where ∇𝑖𝑉 is the gradient of 𝑉 with respect to 𝑋𝑖. Then the energy

𝐸=12∑𝑖𝑚𝑖|𝑋′𝑖|2+𝑉(𝑋)

is constant:

𝐸′=∑𝑖𝑚𝑖𝑋′𝑖⋅𝑋″𝑖+∑𝑖∇𝑖𝑉⋅𝑋′𝑖=∑𝑖𝑋′𝑖⋅(𝐹𝑖−𝐹𝑖)=0.

A spring of stiffness 𝑘 and natural length 𝐿0 joining pieces 𝑖 and 𝑗 has 𝑉 =12𝑘(|𝑋𝑖 −𝑋𝑗| −𝐿0)2. Constant gravity pulling down on piece 𝑖 has potential 𝑚𝑖 𝑔 𝑦𝑖, where 𝑦𝑖 is its height, just as for the bead. When several forces act, we add their potentials. With one way to move, a level set of 𝐸 is a curve, so the energy determines each trajectory. With more pieces, a level set is much bigger. For a single particle moving freely in space, the state has six numbers, and a level set of 𝐸 is five-dimensional. Then 𝐸 no longer tells us the trajectory, but it still tells us where the state can go: it stays where 𝑉(𝑋) ≤𝐸.

Conserved quantities are useful far outside physics. In section 11.2 we followed the hare–lynx model 𝐻′ =𝐻(1 −𝐿), 𝐿′ =𝐿(𝐻 −1) around what looked like closed loops, while still trusting the computation that the loops close. There are no masses or forces here, but there is a conserved quantity:

𝐺=𝐻−ln⁡𝐻+𝐿−ln⁡𝐿.

You can find 𝐺 the same way we found 𝐸, by separating the equation for 𝑑𝐿/𝑑𝐻; see the problems at the end of this chapter. Along a solution,

𝐺′=(1−1𝐻)𝐻′+(1−1𝐿)𝐿′=(𝐻−1)(1−𝐿)+(𝐿−1)(𝐻−1)=0.

So each trajectory stays on one level curve of 𝐺. The function 𝑢 −ln⁡𝑢 decreases until 𝑢 =1, increases after, and grows without bound as 𝑢 →0 and as 𝑢 →∞. So 𝐺 is smallest at the equilibrium (1,1), and its level curves are closed loops around it. The only equilibrium in the quadrant is (1,1), which is not on any of these loops. So the populations go all the way around and return to where they started: the loops really close.

13.4Linearization Around an Equilibrium

Suppose the system can rest at 𝑋0, so 𝐹(𝑋0) =0. To see what happens nearby, we linearize, just as in chapter 12. Write 𝑋 =𝑋0 +𝑈. Since 𝑋0 is constant, 𝑋″ =𝑈″, and the tangent approximation from section 12.3 gives 𝐹(𝑋0 +𝑈) ≈𝐹(𝑋0) +𝐷𝐹(𝑋0) 𝑈 =𝐷𝐹(𝑋0) 𝑈, where 𝐷𝐹(𝑋0) is the Jacobian of 𝐹 at 𝑋0. When the forces come from a potential, 𝐹 = −∇𝑉, this Jacobian is minus the matrix 𝐾 of second derivatives of 𝑉 at 𝑋0. So near rest,

𝑀𝑈″≈−𝐾𝑈.

This is exactly the equation of chapter 10. Every mechanical system near a resting state, whatever its forces, vibrates in modes. That is why we found modes in springs, buildings, and molecules: each was the linearization of a nonlinear system near rest. Recall the row of stretched springs from section 10.1. If each spring obeys Hooke's law, with stiffness 𝑘 and natural length 𝐿0, the exact sideways pull of a spring whose ends differ in height by 𝛿 is 𝑘(1 −𝐿0/√𝑎2+𝛿2)𝛿. Its linearization at 𝛿 =0 is 𝑘(1 −𝐿0/𝑎) 𝛿 =𝑇0𝛿/𝑎, since the spring's tension is 𝑇0 =𝑘(𝑎 −𝐿0). That is exactly the force we used there.

With one piece on a line, 𝐾 is the number 𝑉″(𝑥0), and the linearization is 𝑢″ = −𝑉″(𝑥0) 𝑢. At a valley, this is a spring with frequency √𝑉″(𝑥0). For the pendulum, 𝑉″(0) =cos⁡0 =1, so small swings follow 𝑢″ = −𝑢, with period 2𝜋. For the double well, 𝑉″( ±1) =2, so small oscillations in either well have frequency √2. At a hilltop, 𝑉″(𝑥0) <0, and the linearization is a saddle.

Will the system actually stay near a resting state? Linearization can't tell us. At a valley of 𝑉, where all the eigenvalues of 𝐾 are positive, every mode oscillates, so the linearization rotates in each mode's plane. These are centers, exactly the case where linearization can't decide. But energy can. Suppose 𝑋0 is the bottom of a valley, and measure 𝑉 so that 𝑉(𝑋0) =0. A state that starts near 𝑋0 with a small velocity has a small energy 𝐸. Since 𝐸 never changes and kinetic energy is never negative, 𝑉(𝑋) ≤𝐸 for all time, and the kinetic energy is at most 𝐸. So the state stays in the small region around 𝑋0 where 𝑉 ≤𝐸, moving slowly, forever. Near the bottom of a valley, the system stays near rest.

13.4.1The Elastic Pendulum

Here is a system where the nonlinear terms do something the modes never could. Hang a mass from a spring that can both stretch and swing, like a pendulum whose rod is a spring. With the pivot at the origin, mass 1, stiffness 𝑘, natural length 𝐿0, and gravity 𝑔 pulling down, Newton's law is

𝑋″=−𝑘(|𝑋|−𝐿0)𝑋|𝑋|−𝑔(01).

The first term is the spring's pull, along the spring, proportional to its stretch. At rest the mass hangs straight down, where the spring's pull balances gravity: 𝑋0 =(0, −ℓ) with ℓ =𝐿0 +𝑔/𝑘. Near rest, the linearization has two modes: bouncing up and down with frequency √𝑘, and swinging side to side with frequency √𝑔/ℓ, like a pendulum of length ℓ.

Figure 13.4 A mass on a spring that can bounce and swing, with plots of the size of its swing and of its bounce over time. The buttons choose the stiffness: tuned so that the bounce is twice as fast as the swing, or not.

In the linearization, each mode keeps its own energy forever. If you start the mass bouncing with only a tiny swing, the swing stays tiny. The real spring usually behaves the same way. But tune it so that the bounce is exactly twice as fast as the swing, with 𝑘 =4𝑔/ℓ, and something new happens: the bounce slowly dies down while the swing grows, then the swing dies down while the bounce grows, back and forth. The energy moves between the modes, and only the nonlinear terms can move it.